IEC 61010
 
IEC 61010

Company News

Single Fault Condition: Why the Standard Makes You Short Three Components at Once

A product that is safe when everything works is not a safe product; it is a working product. The single-fault requirement asks what happens when one thing fails, and the answer has to be "still safe".

The complication is that "one thing" is defined by the effect, not by the count. A fault that disables a protection circuit is one fault even if it involves several components.

How the standard frames it

Fault typeExampleWhat is checked
Short or open of a componentCapacitor shorted, resistor openTemperature, leakage, no fire
Failure of insulationClearance bridgedTouch current, dielectric withstand
Failure of a protective deviceFuse bypassedDownstream components, fire
Loss of earthingProtective conductor openTouch current on accessible metal
Overload of a motorRotor lockedWinding temperature, enclosure temperature
Cooling failureFan stoppedAll temperature limits

The requirement is cumulative in a specific way: the worst-case combination of independent faults must be evaluated, and the analysis has to show that the combination is the worst one, not just that it was tested.

The three-component practice

In practice a laboratory will short the components that could fail in the same direction, typically up to three at a time, and check whether the result is still inside the limits. The number three is a convention that reflects the depth of most circuits; the requirement is the analysis behind it.

  • Identify the protection path. What stops the fault from reaching the user, and what protects that?
  • Fail the protection first. Shorting the component that is supposed to fail safely is the interesting test.
  • Measure, do not reason. A calculated 80 °C winding can be 140 °C when the airflow path is blocked by a failed part.
  • Keep the fault in place until stable. Many faults produce a slow rise that ends in a limit breach after an hour.

Recording the analysis

The report needs the fault list, the reasoning for each combination and the measured result for the worst case. A report that says "single fault conditions tested, no hazard" without a list is not evidence of anything.

Our safety test accessories include fault switches and current-limited supplies for this work, and the technical notes give a worked example for a switching supply.

Standards referenced: IEC 61010-1 clause 4.4 and Annex F, IEC 60950-1 clause 1.5 (for comparison), IEC 60601-1 clause 13.

Start with the protection, not the load

The most informative single fault is the one that disables the protection: short the optocoupler that feeds the shutdown comparator, or open the resistor that biases it. Nine times out of ten the resulting temperature rise is larger than any load fault, and the test takes 1 hour instead of a day of analysis.

Then fail the cooling, then the motor, and stop when the analysis shows the next combination is milder.

Practical envelope for a 250 V, 10 A product: the fault is held for 1 h or until thermal equilibrium, temperatures are read every 5 min, and the test ends when 3 consecutive readings differ by less than 1 K. A winding that climbs past 130 °C in that window has failed, whatever it does afterwards. Keep the fault in place for 2 h in the worst case, and check that no accessible surface exceeds 70 K above the 25 °C ambient.

    Standard:       IEC 61032 IEC 60061 IEC 60335 IEC 60529 IEC 60068 IEC 60950 IEC 61010 IEC62368 IEC 60601
    TAG:
Test Probe Go Not Go Gauges Spring Impact Hammer Test Pin Probe Test Probe B Test Probe 18 IP Test Probe
 
Lampholder Gauges Lampcap Gauge Test Probe 11 UL Test Finger Probe Test Vessel Rigid Test Finger Impact Testing
test probe