IEC 61010
 
IEC 61010

Company News

Class II Dielectric Strength: 3,000 V and the Y-Capacitor Path

Class II equipment has no protective earth, so the only thing between a user and the mains is insulation. The dielectric test is the check that the insulation is there, and it is applied at a voltage high enough to find a weakness that a lifetime of mains voltage would eventually find.

The number is usually 3,000 V AC for reinforced insulation on low voltage equipment, and 1,500 V for basic. The test itself takes a minute; the decisions around it take longer.

What is applied where

InsulationTest voltageApplied between
Basic1,000 V to 1,500 VLive parts and accessible metal
SupplementarySame as basicIn series with basic, not separately measurable
Reinforced2,000 V to 3,000 VLive parts and accessible surfaces
Class II enclosure3,000 VInput and output or accessible surface
After humiditySame voltage, sometimes reducedThe condition is the test, not the voltage
Duration1 minuteOr a ramp to the voltage and hold

Reinforced is not twice basic by convention; it is the voltage that a double insulation system has to withstand as a single system, and it is specified separately for each product family.

The Y-capacitor problem

Most Class II products have a Y-capacitor from live to the secondary or to an accessible part, for EMC. At 50 Hz that capacitor is a low impedance compared with the insulation, so the tester sees a capacitive current that has nothing to do with insulation quality. At 2.2 nF and 3,000 V, 50 Hz, the current is about 2 mA, which is already at the trip limit of many testers.

Three ways out, all legitimate and all requiring a statement in the report. Test at DC, where the capacitor charges once and then draws no current. Test at a lower frequency. Or disconnect the capacitor and test the insulation alone, then test the capacitor separately. The one option that is not legitimate is raising the trip limit until the product passes, because that also hides a real defect of the same magnitude.

Testing without damaging the product

  • Ramp rather than switch. A step application produces a charging current spike that trips the tester and stresses the insulation.
  • Discharge afterwards. The specimen holds charge, and a person who touches it gets a shock even though the tester is off.
  • Do not repeat unnecessarily. Every application of the test voltage is a stress. A product that has been tested five times has been aged five times.
  • Test the whole product, not a sample of the insulation. The failure mode being looked for is a creepage path through a contaminated or cracked part, which only exists in the assembly.

Reading a failure

A failure at 3,000 V is not always a design failure. Flux residue, moisture, a metal burr or a cable pinched during assembly all produce a breakdown that disappears after cleaning. Note where the breakdown occurred, inspect that point, and retest a different sample before concluding anything about the design.

A failure that recurs at the same point after cleaning is a design or process issue with creepage or clearance, and it belongs in the layout review, not in the test report. A dielectric strength tester with an adjustable ramp and a DC mode covers both the Class I and Class II cases, and the site index lists the testers by voltage and current range.

Standards referenced: IEC 61010-1; IEC 60335-1.

    Standard:       IEC 61032 IEC 60061 IEC 60335 IEC 60529 IEC 60068 IEC 60950 IEC 61010 IEC62368 IEC 60601
    TAG:
Test Probe Go Not Go Gauges Spring Impact Hammer Test Pin Probe Test Probe B Test Probe 18 IP Test Probe
 
Lampholder Gauges Lampcap Gauge Test Probe 11 UL Test Finger Probe Test Vessel Rigid Test Finger Impact Testing
test probe